It is rarely a total loss. Most wrong sand gets corrected by blending in a higher-quality sand that supplies what the first one lacks.
It costs more than getting it right the first time, and far less than digging it all out. Here is how to tell what is wrong, and what gets mixed in.
The short answer
The fix the trade reaches for is a second sand, not a dumpster.
A measured amount of a higher-quality sand gets mixed through the one you have. Chosen well, it supplies the grip, the fineness or the openness the first sand was missing.
Which second sand depends on what you ride. That is why the fix starts with the discipline, the same as the first order should have.
Start from the symptom
Find the row that sounds like your arena. Four of the six are a blend. Two are not, and no sand will fix them.
| What the arena does | What the sand lacks | What gets blended in | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| rolls underfoot, rides loose, banks up at the rail | Grains too round, or all one size, so nothing holds them | A sub-angular or angular sand, often a little finer, to sit between the grains and lock them | Blend |
| harsh and loose, will not hold a hoofprint | Too coarse for the discipline | A finer sand to fill the gaps. Dressage and hunter/jumper arenas get blended toward fine | Blend |
| sets like a road and packs hard | Grains too sharp, so they lock and keep locking | A cleaner, coarser, sub-angular sand to open the surface back up | Blend |
| dusty a day after watering, slick when wet | Too much silt and clay came in with it | Clean, hard sand dilutes it. Nothing blended in takes the silt and clay back out | Blend helps. It does not cure |
| right sand, but too deep or too shallow | Nothing. There is too much or too little of it | No blend. Take some off, or top up with the same material | Not a blend |
| holds water, or rides differently in patches | Usually the base underneath, not the sand | No sand fixes a base. Have a professional look at it before buying anything | Not a blend |
Why it works
Round grains roll, and sharp ones lock tight and compact. Penn State Extension describes both, and a sub-angular grain sits between the two.
A blend moves the whole surface toward that middle. It works on shape and size. It does not take silt and clay out, and it is a different job from topping up.
Doing it properly
The mistake is ordering the second sand the way the first was ordered: by name, untested. Test it small.
Name the symptom before you name a fix: loose, hard, dusty or deep.
Each one points at a different sand, and adding the wrong second sand makes two problems.
A sample of what is down, dug from below the surface.
And a sample of the sand proposed to correct it, from the pile the load would come off.
Mix the two in a shoebox in the proportion you plan to use. Wet it, pack it and press into it.
Change the proportion and try again. A box costs nothing to get wrong.
New sand adds depth. If the arena is already at the deep end for your discipline, some of the old sand has to come off first.
Spread the new sand evenly, then work it all the way down.
Sand left sitting on top rides as two layers, and a patchy mix rides as two arenas.
Give it time to settle before you judge it.
Adding a little more later is easy. Taking sand back out is not.
What it teaches
Every route out of the wrong sand costs more than the right sand would have. Three things keep you out of it.
Decide what you ride on first, then find who makes it. Sand by discipline has the table.
The better the quality of the sand, the longer it lasts. Cheap sand that breaks down early is bought twice. What drives the cost explains it.
If money is a factor, a decent local sand with a smaller amount of high-quality sand blended in gives good results for less.
If the sand has worn out instead of being wrong from the start, when to replace arena sand is the page you want. If the base is the problem, have a professional look at it. We supply base materials, and a base should be installed by someone who builds them.
Asked after the truck has left
If yours is not here, call and describe what the surface does. We will tell you when a blend is not the answer.
The surface tells you within a few months: it rolls, packs hard, dusts or rides deep. It is rarely a total loss.
Most wrong sand is corrected by blending in a higher-quality sand that supplies what the first one lacks.
That costs more than getting it right the first time, and much less than removing it all.
Usually, yes. If the grains are the wrong shape or size, a measured amount of a second sand blended through the full depth can correct it.
If the problem is silt and clay, a blend only dilutes it. If the problem is the base or the depth, no blend helps at all.
It depends on what the first sand lacks and what you ride. Round, loose sand gets a sub-angular or angular sand to lock it together.
Sand that packs hard gets a cleaner, coarser, sub-angular one to open it up. Dressage and hunter/jumper arenas are blended toward a finer sand, and cutting and barrel pens toward coarser and deeper.
There is no single ratio, because it depends on both sands.
That is why you test the blend in a box before ordering: mix samples of the two in the proportion you plan, wet it, pack it and press into it.
Then call us with what you found and we will work out the tonnage.
Yes. If money is a factor, buy a decent grade of sand locally, bring in a smaller amount of high-quality sand, and blend the two.
With the right pair it rides well for less than hauling in a whole arena of the best material. Choose the pair before you order either one.
Decide what your discipline needs before you look at what is nearby, ask the quarry for its gradation report, and get a sample to test in a box.
Or call us and we will recommend the material. The most expensive mistake in an arena is the first order.
Free quote · by phone
What the yard called it, what you ride, and how the surface behaves. That is usually enough for us to say whether a blend will rescue it, and which sand to recommend for the job.