Skip to content
← Common Questions

Arena drainage · what is holding the water

Why won’t your arena drain?

Often it is not the sand. Arena drainage is usually the base under the footing, or the way the ground was graded.

We do neither of those. So work through this the way a fault is found: where the water sits, where it stalls, what you can check yourself, and what actually changes it.

five patterns
Two of them are not a sand problem at all
one question first
Does your water have a favorite spot?
what we sell
Sand. No bases, no drainage, no construction

Step one · symptom

Which of these is your arena?

Water with a favorite spot is following the ground. Water everywhere at once is being held by the surface.

That one distinction does most of the work on this page.

THE ARENA FROM ABOVE, FOUR HOURS AFTER RAINONE SPOT, EVERY TIMEGRADING OR BASEROUND THE EDGESGRADINGEVENLY, ALL OVERTHE FOOTINGWATER WITH A FAVORITE SPOT IS FOLLOWING THE GROUND. WATER EVERYWHERE IS BEING HELD BY THE SURFACE.
Three arenas, same rain, four hours later. Find the one that looks like yours.
01

One low spot, every time

The ground there sits lower than the ground around it, or the base under it has dished. Water is doing exactly what water does.

Grading or base, not sand

02

Round the edges

Water arriving from outside the arena, or water with nowhere to leave once it reaches the perimeter.

Grading, not sand

03

Evenly, across the whole surface

The water is not getting down through the footing at all. Either the sand holds it, or fines have sealed the bottom of it.

Sand, most likely

04

It drains, then stays greasy for days

Fine material holding moisture in the top of the footing, long after the free water has gone.

Sand

05

It used to drain and now it does not

Fines have migrated down and tightened the footing-to-base line. Or the base itself has silted up over the years.

Both. Check the base too

Two of those five are not sand at all, and a third is only partly. That is the honest split, and it is why we would rather you read this than take a call from us about a load you may not need.

Step two · where it stalls

Down, then out.

A sand arena is not supposed to hold water at all.

Rain passes down through the footing, reaches the base, and leaves along whatever fall the base and the site were built with. There are three places it can stop.

WHEN IT WORKS: WATER PASSES THROUGHFOOTINGINTO THE BASE AND AWAYBASESUB-BASEWHEN IT DOES NOT: THE FOOTING IS SEALEDWATER SITS ON TOPFOOTINGFINES SEALED THIS LINEBASESUB-BASE
01in the footing
Silt and clay between the grains hold water rather than passing it on.

can be the sand

02at the footing-to-base line
Fines packed into that boundary stop behaving like a join and start behaving like a lid.

can be the sand

03under the base, or at the edge
Water is through the footing and has nowhere left to go. Fall, base and perimeter decide that.

never the sand

Step three · go and look

Check this yourself first.

Three checks. A spade, a phone camera and a mason jar between them.

Do all three before you buy anything, including from us.

CUT A SPADE-WIDTH HOLE THROUGH THE FOOTING, THE DAY AFTER RAINSURFACEFOOTING MEETS BASEBASEDRAININGDamp through, no free waterFREE WATERSURFACEFINES SEALED THIS LINEBASESEALEDwater standing on a tight gray line
The same cut, two arenas. The tight line at the bottom is the whole difference.
  1. 01

    walk it four hours after rain

    Photograph every place water is still standing. Do it after the next storm too.

    You are looking for one thing: whether the water has a favorite spot.

  2. 02

    cut one spade-width hole through the footing

    Down to the base, the day after rain.

    Free water standing on a tight line at the bottom means the footing is sealed. Damp the whole way through means it is draining.

  3. 03

    keep a handful from the bottom of that hole

    That is the material doing the holding.

    Run the settling jar test on it and you can see the fine fraction for yourself.

The narrow part that is ours

When it is the sand.

Both ways a footing stops water come down to fine material.

One arrived with the sand. The other was made by the arena, and has been settling to the bottom ever since.

01

silt and clay in the footing

Fine material holds water rather than letting it through. A sand that arrived carrying silt and clay drains slowly from the first day it is down.

It usually dusts badly once it dries out again. Washing and screening take that material out, and both happen at the quarry rather than in your arena.

02

fines that have migrated down

Fine material works its way to the bottom of the footing over years of riding and rain, and collects where the sand meets the base.

Packed tight enough, that line stops behaving like a boundary between two layers and starts behaving like a lid. The arena drained once and now it does not.

Both show as water sitting evenly across the whole surface rather than collecting in one place. If your water has a favorite spot, this section is not your problem.

The same fine material goes airborne once the arena dries out, which is why a surface that puddles in winter so often clouds in summer. One cause, two complaints, six months apart.

Step four · the route out

What actually changes it.

Three of these five rows send you to somebody who is not us.

Drainage is usually a base or a grading problem, and no sand order fixes a base. We would rather tell you that than sell you a load that will not change anything.

START HERE: WHERE IS THE WATER FOUR HOURS AFTER RAIN?IN THE SAME LOW SPOTthe ground there sits lowerGRADING OR BASEROUND THE PERIMETERnowhere to leave at the edgeGRADINGEvenly, or greasy for daysthe footing is holding itTHE SANDIt used to drain, now it does notfines have tightened the bottomSAND, CHECK THE BASE TOOFILLED = WE SELL THE FIX. HOLLOW = WE DO NOT, AND A LOAD OF SAND WILL NOT CHANGE IT.
One question at the root. Two of the four exits are not a sand problem.
Each drainage pattern, what actually changes it, and whose work that is
PatternWhat actually changes itWhose work that is
One low spotBring the level back, or repair the dish in the base beneath itBase or grading contractor
Round the edgesFall away from the arena, and somewhere for water to go once it reaches the perimeterBase or grading contractor
Evenly, all overMaterial with less fine content in it, washed and screened at the quarrySourcing. This one is ours
Greasy for daysThe same fine fraction, and the same answerSourcing. This one is ours
Used to drain, now does notFind out which moved first: the fines in the footing, or the base under itStart with the spade. Then whichever it turns out to be

If it does turn out to be the material, choosing your sand covers what to look for, the calculator turns your dimensions into tons and truckloads, and a footing that packs hard is the same fine material wearing a different complaint.

Asked in the wet

Drainage questions.

If yours is not here, give us a call and describe where the water goes. We will tell you if it is not ours.

Only if the sand is what is stopping the water.

If your footing is full of silt and clay, or fines have sealed the line where it meets the base, then changing the material genuinely changes how the arena drains.

If the water is collecting in one place because the ground there is lower, new sand goes straight on top of the same dish and you get the same puddle in the same spot.

That is why it is worth working out which one you have before anyone quotes you for anything.

Generally yes, because washing removes the silt, clay and organic material that holds water between the grains. It is worth understanding what that does and does not tell you.

Washed describes what was taken out of the sand before it was loaded; it says nothing about what happens after several years of riding, when the grains themselves have broken down and made new fine material.

Washed is a good starting point rather than a settled answer.

Look at whether the problem has a location.

Water that collects in the same corner, the same end or the same low line every single time is following the shape of the ground, and the shape of the ground is a base and grading matter.

Water that sits more or less evenly over the whole surface is being held by the surface itself, which points at the footing.

Neither test is perfect, but between them they usually tell you which trade to call.

No. We source arena materials, and we do no base systems, no drainage work and no construction.

It means we can tell you when the answer is not sand without losing anything by saying it.

If your arena needs base or grading work, a contractor who does that properly is worth having, and we are not going to pretend a load of footing is a substitute for one.

It is a common move and it usually buys a season.

Deeper footing gives the water further to travel before it reaches whatever is stopping it, so the surface feels better for a while.

What it does not do is remove the thing that stopped the water, and you have now added depth, which brings its own problems for the horses working on it.

If the arena is holding water because of the ground underneath it, more sand on top is a delay rather than a fix.

Because both of those are the same fine material behaving differently in different weather.

Silt and clay hold water when it is wet, which is why the arena drains slowly, and they go airborne once they dry out, which is why it dusts.

An arena that puddles in the winter and clouds in the summer is usually telling you one thing twice, and that thing is the fine fraction of the sand.

Free quote · by phone

Tell us where the water sits.

One spot or the whole surface, how long it stays, and whether the arena always did this.

That is usually enough for us to tell you whether the sand is involved. Plenty of the time it is not, and we will say so.

Call (704) 310-6238